Unraveling the Web of Retirement Accounts

April 30, 2024

Planning for retirement often resembles a complex puzzle, with each piece — or, in this case, retirement account — holding a unique role in the financial picture that defines our golden years. 

Navigating the maze of 401(k)s, IRAs, and pension plans can be daunting, if not downright perplexing, even for the savviest of investors.

Understanding Your Options: A Roadmap to Retirement

Imagine finding yourself in an unknown city without a GPS or map. The uncertainty is unnerving. Transpose that feeling onto retirement planning: Without a clear understanding of your account options, the anxiety is palpable.

The three mainstays of retirement accounts are the traditional 401(k), the Roth 401(k), and the traditional and Roth IRAs. Knowing the features of each, such as contribution limits, tax advantages, and early withdrawal penalties, is crucial to devising a solid retirement strategy.

Traditional 401(k)s

For many, the traditional 401(k) is the first line of defense in the retirement account arsenal. Funded through pre-tax withholdings, it effectively reduces your annual taxable income, fostering immediate savings. Beyond this, many employers match a percentage of employee contributions, a factor which transforms the 401(k) into a wealth-building engine through compounding growth.

However, the tax break enjoyed during the contribution phase means the piper will eventually be paid during withdrawal, with the entirety of distributions taxed at your income tax rate at the time. This makes the timing of contributions and withdrawals critical in minimizing long-term tax obligations.

Roth 401(k)s

The Roth 401(k), a relative newcomer established by the Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001, offers a polar alternative to the traditional 401(k). Contributions are made after taxes, with all future withdrawals (following a five-year waiting period and reaching age 59½) being tax-free, provided certain rules are followed.

The Roth 401(k) excels in offering tax diversification within retirement savings, providing a resource of untaxed income in retirement. However, some might find the upfront tax hit and constraints on contribution and withdrawal timing to be limiting factors.

Traditional and Roth IRAs

These individual retirement accounts offer much of the same tax benefits and trade-offs as their 401(k) counterparts. However, they differ on contribution limits and eligibility based on income levels, making them attractive to those seeking supplemental savings opportunities.

Unlike 401(k)s, IRAs afford individuals greater control over investment choices and often lower fees, a welcome feature for those with a penchant for a more hands-on approach to their retirement portfolio.

In assessing which IRA is right for you, it's vital to consider factors such as your tax bracket now versus in retirement, and the imperative of establishing a nest egg of investments less likely to require early withdrawals.

The decision between a Traditional and Roth IRA hinges on current tax rates and future retirement income needs — with the Roth's appeal lying in its tax-free withdrawals, under the assumption that tax rates may increase over time. The Traditional IRA relies on the premise that your tax bracket will be lower in retirement than it is during your earning years.

The Power of Pre-Tax Savings

Pre-tax savings instruments are often lauded for their ability to reduce the immediate sting of taxable income while concurrently fostering investment growth. This is perhaps the primary allure of traditional 401(k)s and IRAs, making them a potent tool in the retirement planning kit. For more tools on retirement planning, check out our blog on 10 essential tips for building wealth and achieving financial security.  

The compounding of tax-free savings over decades can result in significant accumulations, especially when combined with employer-matching programs and regular increases in contributions. Yet, it is prudent to remain cognizant of the deferred tax burden, as it invariably looms on the horizon, often coinciding with retirement — a stage where many unwittingly find themselves in a 'higher' tax bracket than anticipated, due to multiple income streams, part-time employment, or other unforeseen factors.

To mitigate this, a comprehensive approach to retirement planning would include a balance of pre-tax and post-tax (Roth) retirement accounts, producing a tax-diversified retirement income. By forecasting tax brackets and considering additional income sources throughout retirement, one can strategically optimize withdrawals to minimize tax exposure.

The Decline of Defined-Benefit Pensions and the Rise of IRAs and 401(k)s

The traditional pension plan, also known as a defined-benefit plan, has lost ground over the years, gradually yielding to defined-contribution plans such as the 401(k). While the defined-benefit plan offered a guaranteed income stream in retirement, the onus of funding has shifted onto employees with the advent of 401(k)s and IRAs.

The transition to these individual savings accounts has fostered greater responsibility and control over retirement planning but also introduced a measure of uncertainty. Retirees now bear the investment risk and the fluctuation of the resulting nest egg, instead of being insulated by a fixed pension payout.

The Positives of Defined-Contribution Plans

Despite the drawbacks, the flexibility and portability of 401(k)s and IRAs empower individuals to tailor their retirement savings to their specific financial goals and life circumstances. The employer match, an often-cited positive feature of 401(k)s, can significantly accelerate the pace of retirement savings, providing a 'free money' advantage unmatched by traditional pension plans.

Furthermore, the rise of index funds, target-date funds, and online investment platforms has democratized access to sound investment strategies, allowing even novice investors to construct diversified portfolios aligned with their timelines and risk tolerances.

The Drawbacks and How to Navigate Them

Navigating the terrain of defined-contribution plans requires a measured approach. Individual investment choices within 401(k)s can be influenced by behavioral biases and a lack of financial literacy, leading to suboptimal returns. To counter this, education, professional advice, and regular portfolio evaluations are critical in course-correcting as retirement looms closer.

Contributing the full employer-match amount is a non-negotiable step. This is a guaranteed return on investment that, when left unclaimed, translates to lost savings. Lastly, maintaining a line of communication with your future self — through a well-researched and revised retirement plan — can help ensure that the retirement account strategy of today aligns with the lifestyle and financial needs of tomorrow.

Tactical Distributions: RMDs and Planning Your Withdrawals

Retirees often predicate years of planning on the notion of a secure, comfortable retirement. However, the nuances of retirement distributions can prove a formidable challenge, requiring as much foresight as the accumulation phase.

Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)

Upon reaching age 73, owners of traditional retirement accounts must begin taking RMDs, a predetermined distribution mandated by the IRS. Failure to do so results in a hefty penalty, emphasizing the compulsory nature of these withdrawals. Yet, they also present a tax-planned opportunity to manage the gradual distribution of retirement savings, thus balancing the tax implications across multiple years.

The RMD formula considers the prior year-end account balance and life expectancy, providing a prescribed method for slowing the drain on retirement accounts while also adhering to IRS guidelines. Effective planning around RMDs involves assessing existing income streams, such as Social Security benefits or part-time employment, and adjusting their withdrawal strategy to minimize the 'accumulated effect' of taxes on these distributions.

Dipping into the ‘Bucket’ Strategy

A popular approach to planned distributions is the 'bucket' strategy, which involves categorizing various parts of the retirement portfolio for short, mid, and long-term assets. Each bucket carries a unique investment objective, be it for immediate expenses, growth, or longevity, thus guiding the withdrawal rate for each.

Adherence to the rule of 4% — withdrawing 4% of the retirement portfolio in the first year of retirement with annual adjustments for inflation — is a widely recommended path. However, the rule is fallible, and health, lifestyle, investment performance, and other variables may necessitate a more flexible framework.

Integrating Healthcare and Retirement Funding

Finally, a topic that often evades the typical discourse on retirement accounts is healthcare — an expense that can significantly drain retirement savings if not appropriately managed. Medicare provides a buffer, but out-of-pocket costs and supplemental insurance must be factored into the retirement equation.

Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) offer an often-overlooked solution. Funds contributed to an HSA are tax-deductible, grow tax-free, and can be withdrawn tax-free for qualified medical expenses, making it a powerful tool to offset healthcare costs in retirement. For those eligible, contributing the maximum to an HSA in conjunction with retirement account funding can provide a triage of benefits — tax savings, investment growth, and a dedicated healthcare fund.

The Power of Flexibility

The ability to adapt and reassess retirement saving strategies throughout various life stages cannot be overstated. Each retirement account — and their collective potential — should be viewed as a dynamic element within the broader retirement architecture. Early investment in a Roth IRA, strategic maneuvers to manage RMDs, and foresighted planning to include healthcare funding can significantly enhance the efficacy of a retirement plan.

In conclusion, the array of options within the retirement account landscape are tools to a greater end — a robust and enjoyable retirement. Their utilization, optimization, and integration form the crafting of a retirement strategy as individual as the investors they serve. Thoughtful consideration of the pros and cons of each account, against the canvas of personal financial aspirations, marks the path to a well-invested future.


Article contributed by Matt Kline (Investment Advisor).



Herbein Financial Group is a joint venture between Northeast Financial Group, Inc. (“NEFG”) and Herbein Financial Group, LLC (“HFG”).  Investment Management services are provided through NEFG while HFG will provide certain relationship services.

Advisory services provided by Herbein Financial Group, LLC. ("Herbein Financial Group”), an SEC registered investment adviser. Registration as an investment advisor does not constitute an endorsement of the firm by the Securities Exchange Commission or any other securities regulator and does not mean the advisor has attained a particular level of skill or ability. Herbein Financial Group, LLC. only transacts business in states where it is properly notice filed or excluded or exempted from notice filing requirements. A copy of Herbein Financial Groups current Relationship Summary and written disclosure statement discussing its business operations, services, and fees is available upon request from Herbein Financial Group or by going to the SEC's website (www.adviserinfo.gov). 

This newsletter is provided for informational purposes only. This newsletter contains data from third party sources. Although Herbein Financial Group believes these sources to be reliable it makes no representations as to their accuracy or completeness. The information contained herein is based upon certain assumptions, theories and principles that do not completely or accurately reflect your specific circumstances. Information presented herein is subject to change without notice and should not be considered as a solicitation to buy or sell any security. Furthermore, this newsletter may contain certain forward-looking statements that indicate future possibilities. Due to known and unknown risks, other uncertainties and factors, actual results may differ materially. As such, there is no guarantee that any views and opinions expressed herein will come to pass. 

Herbein Financial Group, LLC. is a Registered Investment Advisor registered with the Securities Exchange Commission. This report is for information purposes only and does not constitute a complete description of our services or performance. The information contained in this document is not a solicitation to sell securities or investment advisory services where such an offer would not be legal.

The information discussed is intended to serve as a basis for further discussion with your financial, legal, tax and/or accounting advisors. It is not a substitute for competent advice from these advisors. Herbein Financial Group, LLC. or its advisors are not authorized to practice law or provide legal, tax or accounting advice. If a numerical analysis is shown, the results are neither guarantees nor projections, and actual results may differ significantly. Any assumptions as to interest rates, rates of return, inflation, or other values are hypothetical and for illustrative purposes only. Rates of return shown are not indicative of any particular investment and will vary over time. Any reference to past performance is not indicative of future results and should not be taken as a guaranteed projection of actual returns from any recommended investment.